The Legal Process of Buying Foreclosed Properties in New York

Whether you're a property investor, house flipper, or regular homebuyer, purchasing a foreclosed home can be an effective way to secure a property below market value. Foreclosed homes are often appealing because they are sold at discounted prices, but the process is not as straightforward as a traditional purchase. In New York, foreclosure is judicial, meaning it must go through the court system with strict procedures. Understanding how the process works and what you should expect as a buyer is critical to ensuring that your purchase is valid, enforceable, and ultimately beneficial.

Understanding Foreclosure in New York

Foreclosure occurs when a homeowner cannot keep up with mortgage payments and the lender moves to sell the property to recover losses. In New York, foreclosure remains a significant issue, with about one foreclosure in every 3,962 housing units. Also, because the process goes through judicial oversight, the foreclosure tends to take longer.

Here’s how it generally works:

• Default and Notice – If a homeowner falls behind on payments, the lender issues a notice of default and files a foreclosure lawsuit in court.

• Court Proceedings – The borrower (homeowner) is served and has the opportunity to contest the foreclosure.

• Judgment of Foreclosure and Sale – If the lender wins, the court issues a judgment allowing the property to be sold at public auction.

• Auction Sale – The property is sold, typically at a county courthouse, to the highest bidder.

Identifying Foreclosed Properties

The next step is finding the right foreclosure property and evaluating whether it’s worth your investment of time and money. Some of the ways to find a foreclosure property include:

• Court auctions – These are publicly announced and held at county courthouses.

• Foreclosure auctions – In most cases, you won’t be able to step inside the home before bidding. Properties sold at auction are often still occupied, or may be abandoned and in poor condition.

• Bank-owned (REO) properties – Once a property reverts back to the bank, it is usually listed on the open market through a real estate agent. These homes are the easiest to tour, and buyers generally have the opportunity to conduct inspections before closing.

• Government resources – Agencies like HUD also list foreclosed homes for sale.

Schedule Your Appointment

Due Diligence Before the Auction

Unlike traditional home purchases, buying a foreclosure requires extensive due diligence before bidding. Key areas to review include:

• Property condition – Foreclosed homes are usually sold “as is.” Inspections may not be possible before the auction, but drive-by evaluations and public records can give you clues on the state of the house.

• Title search – This is one of the most critical steps. A foreclosure wipes out the mortgage being foreclosed upon, but other liens and judgments may survive. A thorough title search reveals tax liens, mechanics’ liens, or second mortgages that could become your responsibility.

• Auction rules – Each county may have its own procedures for bidding, deposits, and payment deadlines. Reviewing these ahead of time ensures you’re not caught off guard.

Many buyers work with a real estate attorney at this stage. Attorneys perform due diligence, review auction notices, and advise on potential legal risks.

The Auction Process

Foreclosure auctions in New York are conducted by a court-appointed referee. Here’s what to expect:

1. Auction notice – The sale is advertised at least four weeks in advance. Notices include the date, time, and property details.

2. Bidding – On the auction day, bidders must appear in person, typically at the county courthouse. You’ll need to bring a certified check or bank draft for the required deposit.

3. Winning the bid – The highest bidder wins, provided they can immediately provide the deposit.

4. Referee’s Report of Sale – After the auction, the referee files a report confirming the sale. The buyer then has a set period to pay the remaining balance.

It’s important to note that once you win at auction, you are legally bound to complete the purchase. Backing out could mean losing your deposit and facing potential legal consequences.

Post-Auction Considerations

Winning at auction is only part of the process. Afterward, you’ll need to address several legal and practical issues:

Eviction of Occupants

If the former homeowner or tenants still live in the property, you may need to go through a formal eviction process. In New York, this requires filing in landlord-tenant court. An attorney can help ensure this is done lawfully, as self-help evictions are prohibited.

Clearing Title

Even after the sale, your attorney should confirm that the foreclosure was properly conducted and that no remaining junior liens exist. You may want to consider getting title insurance to protect yourself against future claims.

Recording the Deed

Once the referee delivers the deed and you’ve paid the balance, the deed must be recorded in the county clerk’s office. This officially transfers ownership to you.

Alternative Route – Buying REO Properties

If a property doesn’t sell at auction, it often becomes real estate owned (REO) by the bank. Purchasing an REO is more similar to a traditional real estate transaction:

• The bank lists the property with an agent.

• Buyers can make offers, conduct inspections, and negotiate terms.

• Title insurance and mortgage financing are typically available.

When you get the chance to view a property, it’s important to look for warning signs. Foundation cracks, mold, water damage, or evidence of vandalism can indicate costly repairs down the road. Even if you cannot enter the home, a simple drive-by inspection can reveal whether it looks neglected, vandalized, or still occupied.

For real estate investors, having a contractor walk through the property can be especially valuable. They can provide an estimate of necessary repairs and help you calculate the after-repair value (ARV) of the property. This calculation is key to determining whether the investment makes financial sense.

While REO purchases may cost slightly more than auction deals, they are often less risky because the bank clears liens before selling.

The Role of a Real Estate Attorney

A real estate attorney plays a central role in real estate transactions. For foreclosure purchases, an attorney can:

• The bank lists the property with an agent.

• Explain county-specific auction rules.

• Draft and review documents.

• Handle post-sale issues like evictions or deed recording.

• Having professional legal support ensures you don’t overlook critical details that could cost you significantly later on.

  
  

Buying a foreclosed property in New York can be a smart investment, but the process is complex and filled with legal hurdles. At Curcio Law PLLC, we guide buyers through every step so you can move forward with confidence. Whether you’re an investor or a first-time homebuyer, our team is here to protect your interests and help you secure the right property. Contact us today to get trusted legal support for your foreclosure purchase.